At Modern Luxury, connection and community define who we are. We use cookies to improve the Modern Luxury experience - to personalize content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyze our traffic. We also may share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners. We take your privacy seriously and want you to be aware that we have recently made changes to our Privacy Policy, which can be found here.


The 6 Best Halloween Costume Stores in NYC

Addison Aloian | October 30, 2020 | Culture Lifestyle

The 6 Best Halloween Costume Stores in NYC

Halloween will be looking a little different this year due to the COVID-19 pandemic, but that surely won’t stop New Yorkers from celebrating with some extra safety precautions. We can’t necessarily bar hop or attend a crowded party like in previous years, but there are still plenty of ways to have fun this weekend.

It can be tough to know where to buy a costume, how late the shops are open and if they’ll even carry the apparel you want. Instead of resorting to Target last-minute, it's always better to support the city's local businesses.

We’ve compiled a list of the best Halloween costume stores in NYC for your reference. Don’t waste any more time! Whether you’re throwing a socially-distanced apartment party for your five closest friends or eating at your favorite restaurant in full costume, it’s still Halloween – you still have to be dressed to the nines, and we’ve got you covered.

See also: 8 Ways to Have a Safe and Spooky NYC Halloween This Year


19 W. 21st St. | Website

Abracadabra calls themselves “the world’s most unique store” and certainly lives up to that title. They sell every costume you could possibly want, with both Disney and superhero costumes getting their own section on the website. You can also purchase accessories as intense as prosthetics and fake blood, but don’t leave without checking out their very own magic shop within the store!

Gothic Renaissance

110 4th Ave. | Website

For our edgier readers, this one is for you. An alternative fashion boutique specializing in goth, renaissance, Victorian, cyber, steam punk and fantasy apparel, this shop does not fall short of spooky. Whether you need a corset for your angel costume or platform knee-high boots to be a member of Kiss, Gothic Renaissance has the costume for you.

Screaming Mimis

240 W. 14th St. | Website

Not your typical costume shop, Screaming Mimis approaches costuming from a fashion stylist’s perspective, specializing in vintage clothing. If you need a nice, high-quality costume that will last you through this Halloween and the costumed cocktail work event you’ll attend in two years, this might be the perfect spot to make your purchase.

New York Costumes

808 Broadway | Website

This store claims to have the largest retail selection of costumes, wigs, masks, props and décor in NYC – doesn’t just that description alone make you want to visit? Offering costumes for purchase and rental, you will definitely find what you need at this shop, selling everything from animal and mascot wear, to historical costumes, and everything in between.

Spirit Halloween

Locations in all boroughs | Website

With over 1,000 across the US since 1983 and an iconic reputation, it’s not overdramatic to say that Spirit Halloween is a national treasure. They quite literally have every possible costume you could want – no matter how niche you think yours is. Plus, if you want to stay home for the safety of avoiding COVID-19, they sell every costume online.

Village Party Store

13 E. 8th St. | Website

For all of your costume and party needs, we give you the Village Party Store. Voted the #1 Party Store in NYC by Manhattan Business Recognition, you won’t be disappointed during your visit to this shop. While they carry all of your standard Halloween costumes and accessories, their main specialization is party items. In order to throw your best socially-distanced Halloween bash, you’ll want to make Village Party Store your first stop.

Photography by: Alexi Rosenfeld/Getty Images