Is there anything better than a perfect steak? Yes, a perfect steak with a martini. All jokes aside, these NYC institutions bring the heat when it comes to a killer cut of steak, whether you prefer a filet or a ribeye. Keep reading for our picks for the best steakhouses in NYC.
See also: The 9 Best Italian Restaurants in NYC, According to Foodie Magician
View this post on Instagram
72 W. 36th St. / 212.947.3636 / Website
Regarded as one of the best steakhouses in all of New York City, Keens lives up to its reputation and then some. If you’re dining at this age-old institution, you must order the Legendary Mutton Chop. Trust us on this one, they don’t call it legendary for nothing. Other standout dishes include the chilled seafood tray, roasted buttermilk chicken, and prime porterhouse for three. Yes, you heard us correctly. For three.
Warning: You better come hungry, because the portions here are absolutely massive. Diet, who?
View this post on Instagram
16 W. 22nd St. / 212.401.7986 / Website
Coined as New York City’s “First Korean Steakhouse,” Cote is the temple of all things Korean BBQ–the Carbone of Spicy Rigatoni, and the Via Carota of Cacio e Pepe. While everything on the menu is top-notch, you must order the Butcher’s Feast, an omakase of meats, if you will. The chef’s selection comes with premier USDA Prime and American Wagyu Beef and the most scrumptious Korean accompaniments you’ve ever had.
View this post on Instagram
99 E. 52nd St. / 212.254.3000 / Website
Surprise, surprise! Another Major Food Group haunt makes it onto our list. And yes, this mid-century chophouse actually does live up to the hype. Anything created by the formidable trifecta (Mario Carbone, Rich Torrisi, Jeff Zalaznick) is truly iconic, but nothing beats the New York Strip from The Grill. Succulent, tender, and oh-so-delicious, this steak must be sent from the heavens above. And did you even dine here if you didn’t order the Prime Rib Sammie?
View this post on Instagram
797 3rd Ave. / 212.753.1530 / Website
There’s something undeniably New York about Smith and Wollensky. Maybe it’s the prime Midtown location, signature martinis, or old-school charm, but this storied spot just screams Manhattan. On top of all of that, there’s phenomenal food and an award-winning wine selection. Does it get any better? Menu favorites include the Colossal Lump crabmeat cocktail, 26oz prime rib, and roasted veal chop.
View this post on Instagram
372 Fulton S.t, Brooklyn / 347.689.3677 / Website
Opened in 1874, Gage & Tollner is the definition of a New York City landmark. With a seafood selection just as impressive as their chops, this Brooklyn chophouse is truly the best of both worlds. If you’re dining here, you should ball out on the G&T Chilled Seafood Platter Royale, which comes with lobster, crudo, oysters, clams, and shrimp cocktail. Oh, and be sure to add the caviar. As for steak, the T-Bone Sirloin is one of our favorite cuts in all of New York.
View this post on Instagram
228 W. 52nd St. / 212.586.5000 / Website
Do you know those places that just sound important? The famous Gallaghers Steakhouse is one of them. The menu is somewhat eclectic, with offerings ranging from shrimp and lobster dumplings to Manhattan clam chowder. While you can’t go wrong with anything here, our favorites are the veal chop parmesan and Filet Mignon. As for the latter, diners can choose from a wide variety of preparations, including blue cheese or bone marrow crust, or even a porcini and coffee-flavored rub.
View this post on Instagram
89 South St. / 212.280.4600 / Website
Andrew Carmellini’s Italian Chophouse is unlike any other spot on this list, and we are absolutely here for it. With sweeping views of the Brooklyn Bridge and food worth writing home about, Carne Mare is the ideal place to be wined and dined. After all, the melt-in-your-mouth caviar mozzarella sticks are enough to keep us coming back for more. The Wagyu cuts here are also 10/10, so be sure to order the “Bavetta” steak and the Gorgonzola-cured Striploin.
View this post on Instagram
9 E. 1st St. / 212.460.5255 / Website
Most associate Bowery with its bustling nightlife and post-grads eating pizza at 2 a.m., but we’re obviously in it for the food. Everything here makes our mouths water, but it’s literally illegal to come here and not order the Kung Pao duck wings. Made with toasted peanuts, cilantro, and yuzu rang dressing, this dish is truly a culinary masterpiece. We’re also clinically obsessed with the Chuck Roll Kuroge Wagyu (their take on a steak carpaccio) and the Snake River Wagyu NY Strip.
View this post on Instagram
10 Columbus Cir. / 212.823.9500 / Website
As evident in the name, Porter House Bar & Grill serves one of the best Porterhouse steaks in town. We’re not exaggerating, we would have this dish for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Steak and eggs, anybody? And yes, while this steak is a must-order, there is a plethora of options sure to impress even the pickiest of palettes. Other menu staples include the butter-poached lobster served (extra truffle potato puree, please!), the roasted marrow bone, and the Garganelli bolognese.
View this post on Instagram
109 E 22nd St. / 212.777.1840 / Website
The old-school white tablecloth steakhouse gets a welcome update at Hawksmoor, the hip Gramercy steakhouse where the 20-somethings go to play. For starters, we highly recommend getting an order (or two!) of the Fried Louisiana shrimp, Carolina-spiced pork belly, and steak tartare. For mains, it’s a rite of passage to order the T-bone with roasted bone marrow, Vermont smoked bacon, and a fried egg on top. It’s like a deconstructed 4 Charles burger, but different.
View this post on Instagram
363 Greenwich St. / 212.226.4736 / Website
The downtown culinary scene is popping, and Marc Forgione’s American Cut is no exception. If you’re looking for a chophouse with an ambiance just as luxurious as the food, we’ve got you covered. Reinventing the classic tuna tartare appetizer as we know it, American Cut’s Tuna Tar Tot is truly life-changing. As for the steak, we recommend the Pastrami Ribeye (move aside Katz’s!), or the braised beef short rib. And no, they don’t make it Paleo.
View this post on Instagram
88 Ninth Ave. / 212.858.8899 / Website
From Catch Hospitality Group, this lively spot spanning four approachable dining rooms serves a curated menu of the world's best cuts, alongside rich pairings like roasted Brussels sprouts and twice baked potato, and an extensive wine list that will impress your whole party
View this post on Instagram
4 Charles St. / 212.561.5992 / Website
Simply put, 4 Charles is a vibe. Dimly lit, wood-paneled and brimming with delicious-smelling dishes, there’s everything to love about this NYC institution, and is well worth the struggle of getting a reservation. Everybody knows the famous burger, which is delicious, but we like to opt for the roast prime rib served with natural beef jus and horseradish cream.
View this post on Instagram
56 Ninth Ave. / 212.242.9040 / Website
Unfussy and about as classic as they come, Old Homestead Steakhouse serves up a mean steak, plain and simple. Porterhouse lovers need look no further, as the porterhouse for two leaves nothing to be desired. With a variety of salads, burgers, and seafood also on the menu, there’s something for everyone at this tried and true spot.
View this post on Instagram
178 Broadway, Brooklyn / 718.387.7400 / Website
You can hardly get more classic than Peter Luger, considering this institution opened in 1887. Even over a century later, Peter Luger continues to be a favorite among New Yorkers for its delicious steaks. We personally think any trip to Peter Lugers is incomplete without a slice of the cheesecake.
View this post on Instagram
56 Beaver St. / 212.381.1237 / Website
We could not be happier that Delmonico’s is back and better than ever. One of Manhattan’s oldest restaurants (opened in 1837), this steakhouse reopened after renovations in September and has now returned to serving up delicious seafood and steaks. Be sure to order a few of the sauces and butters for the full experience.
View this post on Instagram
10 E. 33rd St. / 917.261.6217 / Website
Some of the best steak in NYC can be found at Korean barbecue spots, of which HYUN is the perfect example. This hot spot serves up no less than 30 different cuts of unbelievably tender steak. We highly recommend investing in the omakase by HYUN to taste beef like you've never experienced before.
Photography by: Courtesy Getty Images
