By Rachel Feinblatt By Rachel Feinblatt | May 18, 2023 | Food & Drink, Guides,
From dining to shopping, here is everything you need to know about Montauk.
Where to Eat:
Duryea’s Montauk
A trip to Duryea’s Montauk calls for an obligatory Instagram post of not only the colorful lobster cobb salad but also unbeatable sunset views. This Hamptons institution is a must-hit for more reasons than one–with an off the charts seafood game, fresh and flavorful fish and eclectic wine selection, Duryea’s is always a good idea. 65 Tuthill Rd, Montauk, duryeas.com
Crow’s Nest
Seafood and seasoned meat dishes fashioned from organic ingredients complement the restaurant’s rustic charm. 4 Old W. Lake Drive, Montauk, crowsnestmtk.com
Scarpetta
The perfect way to end a calming beach day is with a glass of wine in hand and a reservation at Scarpetta. Whether indulging in a dish from the restaurant’s decadent, world-renowned pasta or a flavorful Branzino, no order is able to disappoint. Expect burrata, seared scallops, ravioli cacio e pepe and lobster Taglioni - now that’s amore. 290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, scarpettarestaurants.com
Navy Beach
Beyond its stunning beachfront, Navy Beach Montauk embraces its nautical heritage with a nod to history. The restaurant's design incorporates elements of vintage naval decor, transporting guests to a bygone era of maritime adventures. The stunning sunsets that paint the sky in a kaleidoscope of colors provide the perfect backdrop for unforgettable moments and create a sense of timeless beauty. 16 Navy Rd, Montauk, navybeach.com
Sel Rrose
Sel Rrose’s menu features a range of dishes that combine classic brunch favorites with modern twists, all while taking in the stunning ocean views. Start your brunch off with the restaurant’s famous Sel Rrose Bloody Mary, made with house-made mix and garnished with bacon, pickled veggies, and a jumbo shrimp. Don't forget to check out Sel Rrose’s Raw Bar, featuring fresh oysters, clams, and shrimp, as well as our delicious Lobster Roll, made with chunks of succulent lobster meat and served on a toasted brioche bun. 4 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, selrrose.com
Where to Stay:
Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
Pack your bags–offering a recently renovated spa and a plethora of activities for the whole family, Gurney’s offers pristine luxury on one of the most beautiful beaches in the area. Sit back, relax and let the waves talk at The Beach Club at Gurney’s Montauk, whose reimagined lounge and recreation areas promote blissful relaxation on your well-needed getaway. The perfect way to end a calming beach day is with a glass of wine and a reservation at Scarpetta–indulge like never before in a world-renowned pasta or a flavorful Branzino. The hotel’s fur-friendly policy hosts dogs in the ultimate digs, whether in the two-bedroom oceanfront residence or a three-bedroom cottage. 290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, gurneysresorts.com/montauk
Marram Montauk
Eponymously named after the dune grass surrounding the boutique resort, Marram Montauk radiates tranquility and effortless luxury. Located in the idyllic town of Montauk, this boutique hotel offers a unique blend of modern sophistication and relaxed beachside charm in each of its amenities. Unwind and rejuvenate with wellness programming like yoga, meditation, tarot card readings and stargazing. Located alongside the resort is Shadmoor State Park, where guests can explore the picturesque landscape, surf the rolling waves or embark on a scenic hike along the coastline. 21 Oceanview Terrace, Montauk, marrammontauk.com
The Surf Lodge
The top destination for surfers and beach enthusiasts looking for an unforgettable experience, The Surf Lodge offers more than just oceanfront views and top-notch amenities. Nested in the heart of Montauk, the laid-back surf-inspired lodgings allow guests to relax and unwind with bike rentals and wellness programming. Add some boogie and flair to the Montauk air at the hotel’s state-of-the-art restaurant, where a stacked setlist of DJs and performers entertain guests and diners. Whether escaping the bustle of the city or simply seeking a getaway, tranquility and ease are guaranteed at The Surf Lodge. 183 Edgemere St, Montauk, thesurflodge.com
Where to Relax:
Seawater Spa @ Gurney’s
The resort’s recently renovated Seawater Spa is a true wellness oasis with a variety of new treatments. New is always better, and Alo Yoga’s beauty and skincare line will bring its a-game by introducing its first-ever spa treatment menu with products to ensure a youthful countenance. After all, who can resist a Swedish Flow massage or Deep Sea Undaria Algae massage from its expert therapists? 290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, gurneysresorts.com/montauk
Montauk Salt Cave
Salt therapy sessions, spa treatments and healing sessions are all available in a pink Himalayan salt cave. Salt therapy works as an alternative treatment for asthma, allergies, anxiety, inflammation, skin issues and common colds. By simply breathing, your body can reap the healing benefits of salt therapy. 552 W. Lake Drive, Montauk, montauksaltcave.com
Where to Shop:
Indy Home
NYC interior designer Beverly Bartfeld, serving residences in NYC, the Hamptons and Nantucket, now has a design boutique in Montauk. Bartfeld’s style is chic, comfortable and affordable. Interior design and home accessory consultation services offer upscale design work that feels easy and unpretentious and is also functional. 71 S. Elmwood Ave., Montauk, indyhomedesign.com
QuincyMTK
Inspired by the ocean and her Montauk roots, pro-surfer and entrepreneur Quincy Davis presents her favorite, hand-picked items in her very own store. Radiating a laid back and beachy aesthetic, her items are the ultimate Montauk curation. 28 S Etna Ave., Montauk, quincymtk.com
Wyld Blue
As you enter Wyld Blue, you are greeted by a treasure trove of unique and enchanting items. The store is a haven for those seeking a touch of magic in their lives—a place where fantasy and reality coexist harmoniously. From handmade jewelry adorned with sparkling crystals to hand-painted seashells that seem to hold secrets of the sea, every item at Wyld Blue has a story to tell. 716 Montauk Highway, wyldblue.store
Road to Nowhere
The collection includes an eclectic mix of clothing and accessories for men and women, from bohemian dresses and beachy cover-ups to edgy leather jackets and statement jewelry. 33 Carl Fisher Plaza, Montauk, roadtonowhereclothing.com
Pre-Dinner Drink:
Montauk Brewing Co
Founded by three lifelong friends, Montauk Brewing Company embodies the spirit and lifestyle of the community it serves. From their flagship beer–the Montauk Summer Ale–to their seasonal and limited-edition releases, each colorful can captures a taste of Montauk through high-quality ingredients and traditional brewing methods. Whether seeking an elevated happy hour experience or simply just looking to indulge like never before, take a trip to its taproom and outdoor seating that overlooks the bustling Montauk scene. 62 S Erie Ave., Montauk, montaukbrewingco.com
Talya
Inspired by the beaches of Montauk, the French Riviera and the Mediterranean, Tayla presents elevated Mediterranean cuisine by chef Lechantoux at Ruschmeyers Hotel. 161 2nd House Road, Montauk, taylarestaurant.com
Where to Hit the Town:
Surf Lodge
When the clock strikes 5PM on the East End, put on your dancing shoes and head to The Surf Lodge. This electric spot offers a myriad of Instagrammable moments and memories, whether indulging in a lobster roll and rosé from its restaurant or admiring summer sunsets from its luxurious lodgings. 183 Edgemere St, Montauk, thesurflodge.com
Maison Close
This hot spot is an intimate eatery that effortlessly intertwines beachside dining with the lively atmosphere and shared space of a French brasserie. 435 E. Lake Drive, Montauk, maisoncloserestaurant.com
Cultural Experiences:
Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum
The world-famous Montauk Point Lighthouse is located at the tip of Eastern Long Island’s South Fork. Be sure to take a coastal walk along the preserve surrounding the lighthouse. 2000 Montauk Highway, Montauk, montauklighthouse.com
Hidden Gem: Shadmoor State Park- take a short hike on this trail and experience breathtaking ocean views like no other.
Photography by: Photo courtesy of the Surf Lodge